Bakehouse 23

We are a from scratch, small batch bakery located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

From-Scratch Nostalgia — No Mixes, No Shortcuts.

Just real ingredients and classics like Oatmeal Cream Pies and Kosmic Brownies!

View Our Menu

Need custom treats for a wedding or event?

Let’s create something unique—pies, cheesecakes, or even a giant brookie!

Catering & Special Orders

We love supporting local!

Find fresh bread from North Shore Boulangerie and crackers from Empress Baking Co. at our bakery.

See Our Partners

Welcome to Bakehouse 23, a from-scratch, small-batch bakery located in South Milwaukee where everything is made with real ingredients, no shortcuts—just bold flavors and nostalgic treats to feed your inner fat kid. From our take on 80s and 90s snack classics to fresh-baked breads, sandwiches, and our signature Godzilla chili, there’s always something new to try. Stop in for a treat, grab lunch, or chat with us about custom orders and catering!

Stop by for a treat or let us cater your next event with custom-made desserts.

Whether you’re craving a nostalgic sweet or need a one-of-a-kind dessert spread, we’ve got you covered.

Let’s Connect