About Us
Welcome to Our Small Batch, From-Scratch Bakery
At our bakery, everything is made from scratch—no pre-made mixes, no bucket frostings, just real ingredients and real baking. We specialize in nostalgic treats inspired by the ’80s and ’90s, including our take on Little Debbie classics like Oatmeal Cream Pies, HoHo Cake, and Kosmic Brownies. Be sure to check out our sweet lunchbox collection!
Our bakery is small but mighty. We bake in small batches to offer the most variety, seasonal flavors, and a rotating menu. Along with our baked goods, we serve grab-and-go sandwiches, daily soups, and our signature Godzilla Chili, plus weekend specials you won’t want to miss.
Minimal Waste, Maximum Flavor
As a classically trained, prize-winning pastry chef, Sarah has mastered the art of using ingredients creatively to minimize food waste while crafting unique and delicious treats. This is why we don’t post a set menu—our offerings change frequently! To stay up to date, follow us on social media or give us a call before stopping by. We’re happy to answer your questions.
Supporting Local Bakers & Makers
We partner with local artisans to bring you the best snacks and baked goods all in one place.
- Empress Baking Company crackers pair perfectly with our house-made dips.
- North Shore Boulangerie / Wildflour delivers fresh-baked bread daily, available in limited quantities.
We love supporting other small businesses and believe in bringing our community the best locally made products.
Where you can find our treats around town?
We are lucky to partner with some of your favorite local dining establishments. You can find our baked goods at the following restaurants:
Riverwest
Wonderland
732 E Burleigh Street
Milwaukee, WI 53212
Downtown
Swingin’ Door Exchange
219 E Michigan Street
Milwaukee, WI 53202
Suburbs
Avenue Coffee House
8652 S Market Place
Oak Creek, WI 53154
Our Awards & Recognitions
We’re honored to have received recognition for our passion and dedication to baking.
- Winner of Food Network’s Sweet Genius – October 2012
- Wisconsin Bakers Association – Best Chocolate Chip Cookie, 2020
- Shepherd Express – Best New Retail Store, 2023
Shop Our Exclusive Merchandise
Show your love for our bakery with locally designed and printed apparel. Stop in to grab yours today!
T-Shirts – $25
Hoodies – $50
Print made by local artist Lauren Marvell
All made by local screen printer Shaky Hands